Partial Automation Investigations

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Below are our completed and ongoing investigations that involved a vehicle being operated in a partial automation mode at the time of the crash. The completed investigations describe the issues we examined, link to the investigation page ​where we detail the crash and state the probable cause, and link to the other relevant documents and the complete public accident docket. The ongoing investigations provide a succinct description of the preliminary factual information.​ 

​​​For links ​to Related Automated Vehicle Topics​

​​​Completed In​vestigations​​

Williston​​, ​Florida​​​

The May 7, 2016, crash in Willi​ston, Florida​, was the first fatal crash in the United States involving a vehicle operating in a partial automation mode at the time of the crash. We examined these safety issues:

  • ​​​partial automation system capabilities and limitations​
  • driver automation overreliance
  • data recording requirements


Read:



Culver City, California
The January 22, 2018, crash in Culver City, California, involved a vehicle operating in partial automation mode that crashed into the back of a stopped fire truck partially blocking the travel lane. We examined these safety issues:
  • limitations of the partial automation system
  • method of monitoring driver engagement
  • driver distraction and automation overreliance





Delray Beach, Florida
​The March 1, 2019, fatal crash in Delray Beach, Florida, involved a vehicle operating in partial automation mode that struck the trailer of a combination vehicle crossing a state highway, in a sequence that closely resembles the Williston crash. We examined these safety issues:
  • limitations of the partial automation system
  • method of monitoring driver engagement
  • automation overreliance


Read:

​Mountain View California​​
The March 23, 2018, crash in Mountain View, California was a fatal crash involving a vehicle operating in partial automation mode that veered into a gore area and struck a previously damaged crash attenuator at highway speed; a postcrash fire ensued. We examined these safety issues:
  • ​limitations of the partial automation system and the method of monitoring driver engagement
  • federal requirements for collision avoidance systems
  • driver distraction and automation overreliance​

 
​Read:

Ongoin​g Investigations

San Antonio, Texas​​

The February 24, 2024, crash in San Antonio, Texas, ​involved a vehicle operating in a partial automation mode that crashed into the back of a stopped sport utility (SUV) vehicle. As a result of the crash, the driver of the stopped SUV was fatally injured. These are the additional basic facts about the crash:​

  • Occurred on eastbound I-10, about 9:50 p.m. local time
  • The weather was clear and roadway lighting was present
  • The speed limit was 70 mph​​






Philadelphia, Pennsylvania ​ 
The March 3, 2024, crash in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, involved a vehicle operating in a partial automation mode that crashed into the back of a stationary passenger vehicle,​ which then collided with another stationary passenger vehicle. 

The drivers of these stationary vehicles were outside their cars at the time of the crash sequence. As a result of the crash, the drivers of the stationary vehicles were fatally injured. These are the additional basic facts about the crash:

  • ​​​​Occurred on northbound I-95, about 3:20 p.m. local time
  • The weather was clear, and roadway was dry
  • ​​The speed limit was 45 mph​




​​​​​​